Cherry MX Red vs Cherry MX Silver Speed Silver Switches

When it comes to mechanical keyboards, the choice of key switches can significantly impact your typing and gaming experience. Among the plethora of options available, Cherry MX switches have stood as a gold standard for years, offering a range of switch types, each with its unique characteristics.

In the world of Cherry MX switches, two popular contenders often find themselves in the spotlight: Cherry MX Red and Cherry MX Speed Silver switches. These switches share similarities, but they also feature distinct attributes tailored to different preferences and use cases. 

We'll delve into the difference between Cherry MX Red and Speed Silver switches. We'll shed light on their features, pros, cons, and more of these different types of switches. We'll explore the battle of Cherry MX Speed vs. Cherry MX Red switches and unravel which one reigns supreme in your quest for the perfect mechanical keyboard experience.

Understanding Mechanical Switches

Mechanical switches are a specialized type of key switch found in mechanical keyboards. Known for their robustness, tactile feedback, and distinct keypress audibility, they stand apart from conventional keyboards that typically employ rubber dome switches. Mechanical switches incorporate individual mechanical components for each key, offering unique characteristics.

1. Actuation Mechanism: Mechanical switches boast an exceptional actuation mechanism for registering key presses. How do mechanical switches work? When a key is pressed, it engages a physical switch. These switches typically fall into one of the following types:
   • Tactile: These switches furnish feedback through a noticeable bump at the actuation point, giving users a clear indication that their keypress has been recognized. Cherry MX Brown switches exemplify this tactile variety.
   • Clicky: In addition to a tactile bump, clicky switches also emit an audible click sound upon actuation. Cherry MX Blue switches, for instance, are renowned for their clicky attributes.
   • Linear: Linear switches lack the tactile bump and auditory click, resulting in a smooth and consistent keystroke. Cherry MX Red and Speed Silver switches are exemplars of linear switches.
2. Actuation force: Each mechanical switch features a specific actuation force requirement for keypress registration. Lighter switches necessitate less force, while heavier switches demand more. This factor can significantly impact typing speed and comfort.
3. Actuation point: The actuation point specifies the distance a key must travel before the switch acknowledges a keypress. Variations exist across switch types and brands.
4. Travel distance: Mechanical switches typically deliver a consistent and precise travel distance, outlining the distance a key can be depressed.
5. Durability: A prominent advantage of mechanical switches lies in their robustness. Mechanical switches are quite durable, designed to withstand a substantial number of keypresses, often measured in the millions. This ensures extended longevity, especially for avid typists or gamers.
6. Customizability: Many mechanical keyboards offer the flexibility to replace individual switches, empowering users to select switches that align with their preferences. This customization enhances the overall typing or gaming experience.
7. Key rollover and anti-ghosting: Mechanical keyboards commonly incorporate features like N-key rollover and anti-ghosting, ensuring accurate registration of every keypress, even when multiple keys are pressed simultaneously.
8. Typing sound: The sound produced by mechanical switches varies depending on the switch type (tactile, clicky, or linear). This characteristic often hinges on personal preference, with some individuals favoring the audible feedback of clicky switches while others opt for quieter alternatives.

What are Cherry MX Switches?

Cherry MX switches, produced by the German company Cherry GmbH, have established themselves as a prominent brand of mechanical switches used extensively in mechanical keyboards. Renowned for their quality, resilience, and adaptability, they have become the preferred switches on the market among keyboard enthusiasts and gamers alike. Cherry MX switches are some of the best mechanical switches and are available in a variety of types, each tailored to provide distinct qualities that cater to a wide range of typing and gaming preferences.

Different Types of Cherry MX Switches

It's fascinating to explore the variety of mechanical keyboard options, each offering unique characteristics and advantages. Here's a list of common types of Cherry MX switches:

1. Cherry MX Red

• Type: Linear
• Tactile Bump: No
• Audible Click: No
• Actuation Force: Typically around 45-50g
• Keypress Feel: Smooth and consistent
• Typical Use Cases: Gaming (especially preferred by gamers who require rapid keypresses), general typing for those who prefer a quiet keystroke.

2. Cherry MX Speed Silver (also known as Cherry MX Silver or Cherry MX Speed)

• Type: Linear
• Tactile Bump: No
• Audible Click: No
• Actuation Force: Typically around 45g
• Keypress Feel: Extremely smooth and consistent
• Typical Use Cases: Gaming (specifically designed for rapid and precise keypresses), tasks requiring swift typing speed.

3. Cherry MX Blue

• Type: Tactile and Clicky
• Tactile Bump: Yes
• Audible Click: Yes (produces a distinctive click sound)
• Actuation Force: Typically around 50g
• Keypress Feel: Tactile and auditory feedback, typists who enjoy clicky keys and a noticeable actuation point often prefer these switches.

4. Cherry MX Brown

• Type: Tactile
• Tactile Bump: Yes
• Audible Click: No
• Actuation Force: Typically around 45-50g
• Keypress Feel: Tactile feedback without the clicky sound, a balance between tactile response and quiet operation.

5. Cherry MX Black

• Type: Linear
• Tactile Bump: No
• Audible Click: No
• Actuation Force: Typically around 60g
• Keypress Feel: Heavier keypresses, smooth linear action, preferred by some gamers for more resistance.

6. Cherry MX Green

• Type: Tactile and Clicky
• Tactile Bump: Yes
• Audible Click: Yes (similar to Cherry MX Blue)
• Actuation Force: Typically around 70-80g
• Keypress Feel: High resistance, both tactile and clicky feedback, suitable for typists who prefer a heavier keypress.

Cherry MX Red Switches

You're about to delve into the world of Cherry MX Red switches, a brand of linear mechanical switches. We'll explore their unique features and characteristics and weigh up the pros and cons of using them on your keyboard.

Features and Characteristics of the Cherry MX Red Switches

Cherry MX Red switches are linear switches characterized by their smooth and quiet keypresses, low actuation force, and absence of tactile feedback. 

1. Switch Type: Cherry MX Red switches fall into the category of linear switches.
2. Tactile Bump: Cherry MX Red switches do not have a tactile bump, which means there is no noticeable resistance or bump when you press a key.
3. Audible Click: These switches do not produce an audible click sound when pressed, resulting in a quiet keypress.
4. Actuation Force: Cherry MX Red switches typically have a low actuation force, typically around 45-50 grams. This means it doesn't require much force to register a keypress, making them easy to actuate quickly.
5. Keypress Feel: Cherry MX Red switches offer a smooth and consistent keystroke without any tactile feedback or audible noise. The lack of resistance and feedback allows for fast and effortless keypresses, making them popular among gamers.
6. Typical Use Cases: Cherry MX Red switches are primarily favored by gamers. Their linear design and low actuation force make them ideal for rapid and precise keypresses in gaming scenarios. However, they can also be suitable for general typing tasks if you prefer a light and quiet keystroke.
7. Durability: Cherry MX switches, including Cherry MX Red, are known for their durability and longevity. They are rated for millions of keypresses, ensuring that they can withstand heavy use over time.
8. Customizability: Some mechanical keyboards with Cherry MX Red switches allow for switch replacement, giving users the option to customize their keyboard with different switches to suit their preferences.

Pros and Cons

Weighing the pros and cons, you'll find some key advantages and potential drawbacks to consider in your decision-making process. Cherry MX Red switches are excellent for those who want smooth and fast key presses as well as their quiet operation. However, they may not be the best choice for users who prioritize tactile feedback or do a lot of typing. 

Pros

1. Smooth and fast typing/gaming: Cherry MX Red switches are known for their linear design, which means there's no tactile bump or audible click. This smooth and consistent keystroke allows for rapid and effortless typing or gaming, making great for gaming---for gamers who need to execute quick and precise keypresses.
2. Quiet operation: These switches are relatively quiet compared to clicky switches like Cherry MX Blue. The absence of an audible click makes them suitable for environments where noise is a concern, such as offices or shared spaces.
3. Customizability: Many mechanical keyboards with Cherry MX Red switches offer the option to replace switches. This customization allows users to tailor their keyboard to their specific preferences, which can be a significant advantage for enthusiasts.
4. Durability: Cherry MX switches, including Cherry MX Red, are built to last. They are rated for millions of keypresses, ensuring that they can withstand heavy use without losing their performance.

Cons

1. Lack of tactile feedback: Cherry MX Red switches do not provide tactile feedback, which some users may miss if they prefer a more pronounced keystroke feel. The absence of feedback can lead to accidental keypresses if you're not used to the linear design.
2. Not Ideal for typists: While Cherry MX Red switches are excellent for gaming, they may not be the best choice for extensive typing tasks, especially if you're accustomed to switches with tactile bumps. Typists who rely on tactile feedback for accuracy may find Cherry MX Red switches less satisfying.
3. Actuation force sensitivity: The light actuation force required to register a keypress (typically around 45-50 grams) can lead to accidental keypresses for users with a heavy typing hand. It may take some time to adjust to the sensitivity of these switches.

Cherry MX Speed Silver Switches

In your exploration of mechanical keyboard switches, you've come across the Cherry MX Speed Silver Switches. We'll dive into their unique features and characteristics, comparing them to the previously discussed Cherry MX Red Switches. You'll gain insights into their pros and cons, equipping you with the information you need to choose the switch that best fits your needs.

Features and Characteristics of the Cherry MX Speed Silver Switches

Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are linear switches characterized by their ultra-smooth and rapid keypresses, low actuation force, and absence of tactile feedback. However, their lack of tactile feedback may not be as appealing to typists who rely on feedback for accuracy. Let's take a look at the Cherry MX Speed Silver switch.

1. Switch Type: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches belong to the category of linear switches.
2. Tactile Bump: These speed switches do not have a tactile bump, which means there is no noticeable resistance or bump when you press a key.
3. Audible Click: Similar to other linear switches, Cherry MX Speed Silver switches do not produce an audible click sound when pressed, resulting in a quiet keypress.
4. Actuation Force: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are known for their low actuation force, typically around 45-50 grams. This means they require minimal force to register a keypress, facilitating rapid and precise keystrokes.
5. Keypress Feel: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches offer a smooth and consistent keystroke with no tactile feedback or audible noise. The linear design and low actuation force make them exceptionally responsive, making them well-suited for tasks that demand fast and accurate keypresses.
6. Typical Use Cases: These switches are specifically designed for gaming, where speed and responsiveness are crucial. Gamers who need to execute quick actions, such as double-tapping or rapid keypress sequences, often prefer Cherry MX Speed Silver switches.
7. Durability: Like other Cherry MX switches, Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are built to be durable and are rated for millions of keypresses, ensuring long-lasting performance.
8. Customizability: Some mechanical keyboards with Cherry MX Speed Silver switches allow for switch replacement, giving users the flexibility to customize their keyboard to their preferences.

Pros and Cons

Cherry MX Speed Silver switches, like any mechanical switch, come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons of Cherry MX Speed Silver switches:

Pros

1. Lightning-fast response: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are renowned for their rapid actuation. With an extremely low actuation force and a short key travel distance, they are one of the fastest switches available. Gamers can execute quick actions with minimal effort, enhancing their gaming performance.
2. Smooth and linear keypress: These switches offer a smooth and linear keypress without any tactile bump or audible click. The consistent keystroke makes them suitable for tasks requiring precise and rapid keypresses.
3. Quiet operation: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are relatively quiet, which is ideal for environments where noise is a concern, such as shared workspaces or gaming with others in the vicinity.
4. Customizability: Some mechanical keyboards featuring Cherry MX Speed Silver switches allow for switch replacement, allowing users to customize their keyboard with different switches to match their preferences.
5. Durability: Cherry MX switches, including Cherry MX Speed Silver, are known for their durability and longevity. They can withstand heavy use and are rated for millions of keypresses.

Cons

1. Absence of tactile feedback: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches, like other linear switches, do not provide tactile feedback. This absence of tactile bump and audible click may not be ideal for users who prefer a more tactile and clicky keypress feel.
2. Accidental keypresses: Due to the light actuation force (typically around 45-50 grams) and the absence of a tactile bump, users with a heavy typing hand might experience accidental keypresses until they adjust to the sensitivity of these switches.
3. Typing experience: While Cherry MX Speed Silver switches excel in gaming scenarios, they may not be the best choice for extended typing sessions, especially if you value tactile feedback. Typists who rely on tactile feedback for accuracy may find these switches less satisfying.

Comparison: Cherry MX Red vs Cherry MX Speed Silver

We will delve into a comparison of these two switches, focusing on their performance in typing and gaming, as well as their noise levels.

Typing Experience

Let's compare the typing experience of using Cherry MX Red and Cherry MX Speed Silver switches:

Cherry MX Red Switches

1. Keypress feel: Cherry MX Red switches offer a smooth and consistent keystroke without any tactile feedback or audible click. This results in a linear and frictionless typing experience, where the keypress feels the same from the start of the press to the actuation point.
2. Actuation force: Cherry MX Red switches typically require a light actuation force, typically around 45-50 grams. This light force makes it easy to press keys quickly and with minimal effort.
3. Quiet operation: Cherry MX Red switches are relatively quiet compared to clicky switches, making them suitable for quiet environments and shared spaces.
4. Typing comfort: While Cherry MX Red switches can be comfortable for typing, their lack of tactile feedback can lead to more accidental keypresses for users who are heavy-handed typists. It may take some time to adjust to the light and linear feel.

Cherry MX Speed Silver Switches

1. Keypress feel: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches provide an exceptionally smooth and linear keystroke, similar to Cherry MX Red switches. They lack tactile feedback and audible clicks, resulting in a consistent and frictionless typing experience.
2. Actuation force: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches also require a low actuation force, typically around 45-50 grams, which allows for quick and effortless keypresses.
3. Speed and responsiveness: These switches are specifically designed for speed and rapid keypresses. Their short key travel distance and low actuation force make them incredibly responsive, enhancing typing speed for those who are accustomed to their light touch like programmers using the best keyboards for programming.
4. Typing comfort: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are optimized for speed and responsiveness, which can be advantageous for gamers. However, for typists who rely on tactile feedback for accuracy, the absence of a tactile bump may lead to a less satisfying typing experience, especially during extended typing sessions.

Gaming Performance

Let's compare the gaming experience of using Cherry MX Red and Cherry MX Speed Silver switches:

Cherry MX Red Switches for Gaming

1. Keypress Feel: Cherry MX Red switches offer a smooth and consistent keystroke with no tactile feedback or audible click. This linear and frictionless keypress allows for rapid and effortless keypresses.
2. Actuation Force: Cherry MX Red switches typically require a light actuation force, around 45-50 grams. This light force makes it easy to press keys quickly and with minimal effort, reducing finger fatigue during extended gaming sessions.
3. Responsiveness: The lack of a tactile bump in Cherry MX Red switches means that there's no resistance when pressing a key, resulting in quick and responsive keypresses. Gamers can execute rapid actions and commands with ease.
4. Quiet Operation: Cherry MX Red switches are relatively quiet compared to clicky switches, making them suitable for gaming in shared environments where noise is a concern.
5. Typing and Gaming Balance: Cherry MX Red switches strike a balance between gaming and typing. While they are a great option for gaming, they can also provide a comfortable typing experience, making them versatile for users who do both.

Cherry MX Speed Silver Switches for Gaming

1. Keypress Feel: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches offer an exceptionally smooth and linear keystroke, similar to Cherry MX Red switches. They lack tactile feedback or an audible click, resulting in a consistent and frictionless gaming experience.
2. Actuation Force: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches also require a low actuation force, typically around 45-50 grams. This light force facilitates rapid and effortless keypresses, crucial for quick in-game actions.
3. Speed and Responsiveness: These switches are specifically designed for speed and responsiveness. Their short key travel distance and low actuation force make them exceptionally fast and precise for gaming scenarios, such as first-person shooters and real-time strategy games.
4. Optimized for Gaming: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are optimized for gaming performance, particularly for tasks that demand quick and precise keypresses. They excel in situations where milliseconds can make a difference.
5. Typing Considerations: While Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are outstanding for gaming, they may not be as comfortable for extended typing sessions, especially for users who rely on tactile feedback for typing accuracy, that can also be perfected using a ortholinear keyboard.

Noise Level

Let's compare the noise level of these Cherry switches:

Cherry MX Red Switches

• Noise Level: Cherry MX Red switches are relatively quiet when compared to clicky switches like Cherry MX Blue or Green. They produce a soft, muffled sound when the key bottoms out or when you release a key. The absence of an audible click makes them a good choice for quieter environments like offices or shared spaces.

Cherry MX Speed Silver Switches

• Noise Level: Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are also relatively quiet, similar to Cherry MX Red switches. They do not produce an audible click when the key is pressed or released. The sound is a soft, subdued noise when the key bottoms out, making them suitable for quiet environments as well.

Final Verdict: Which Cherry MX Switch is Better for Your Keyboard?

The choice between Cherry MX Red and Cherry MX Speed Silver switches depends on your specific needs, preferences, and how you intend to use your hot-swappable keyboard. There is no universally "better" switch; it largely comes down to personal preference and the tasks you prioritize. Here are some considerations to help you decide:

Choose Cherry MX Red switches for:

1. Balanced Usage: You use your keyboard for a mix of gaming and typing. Cherry MX Red switches strike a balance between gaming performance and typing comfort.
2. Smooth Keypress: You prefer a smooth and linear keypress with no tactile feedback or audible clicks.
3. Light Actuation: You want a low actuation force that allows for quick and effortless keypresses, reducing finger fatigue during long typing or gaming sessions.
4. Quiet Operation: You value a relatively quiet typing experience, making Cherry MX Red switches suitable for shared workspaces or environments where noise is a concern.

Choose Cherry MX Speed Silver switches for:

1. Gaming Focus: You prioritize popular gaming and need a keyboard optimized for speed and responsiveness. Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are specifically designed for fast-paced gaming.
2. Ultra-Fast Keypresses: You want the fastest possible keypresses. Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are known for their extremely short key travel distance and low actuation force, making them among the fastest switches available.
3. Linear and Quiet: You prefer a linear keypress with no tactile bump or audible click while still maintaining a relatively quiet typing experience.
4. Not Extensive Typing: You don't engage in extensive typing tasks or aren't reliant on tactile feedback for typing accuracy. Cherry MX Speed Silver switches may be less comfortable for extended typing sessions.

Ultimately, the "better" type of switch depends on your personal preferences and primary use case. Check also our article on lubricating keyboard switches for proper maintenance of your keyboard.